Fire Door Repair vs Replace: How to Decide (and When You Have No Choice)
Repair or Replace? The Question Every Fire Door Survey Comes Back To
After every inspection we hand a report to the Responsible Person and the first question is always the same: "Can we repair these or do we have to replace them?" The honest answer depends on whether the defect sits inside the door's original fire test evidence — and that's a technical line, not a commercial one.
This is the framework our BM TRADA Q-Mark certified surveyors use on every job.
The Five Tests We Apply on Site
Every defect goes through five tests before we recommend repair or replacement:
- Is there traceable test evidence? Plug, label, manufacturer's data sheet — any of these proves what the door was tested as. No evidence, no compliant repair — the door must be replaced with a certified one.
- Is the core sound? The door's fire-resisting performance comes from its core. A cracked, water-damaged or impact-damaged core cannot be repaired — only replaced.
- Is the defect a "component" or "substrate"? Seals, ironmongery, signage, glazing beads, intumescent strips — all components, all repairable like-for-like. Door leaf damage, frame warping, missing fire-resisting plasterboard around the opening — substrate problems, often require replacement.
- Will the repair stay within the original test evidence? A like-for-like seal swap stays inside the evidence. Adding glazing to a solid-tested door does not — the door has never been tested in that configuration.
- Is the door still fit for purpose? An FD30 door in a location now requiring FD60 (a common finding after a fresh fire strategy) must be replaced regardless of condition.
If a defect passes all five, we repair. If it fails any, we replace and tell you why in writing.
What's Lawfully Repairable
The vast majority of fire door defects we see across Lincolnshire and the East Midlands are repairable:
- Worn or missing intumescent strips — replaced to the manufacturer's specification using the original tested profile.
- Damaged smoke seals — fitted to match the original tested configuration.
- Faulty self-closing devices — swapped for a CE-marked closer of equivalent performance with the original tested mounting.
- Non-compliant or worn hinges — replaced with fire-rated alternatives per the manufacturer's data sheet (typically 3 hinges per leaf, CE-marked, intumescent washered).
- Missing or non-compliant signage — installed to BS 5499 / BS EN ISO 7010.
- Minor gap issues — frame or leaf planed to restore 3mm tolerance (top and sides) and 8mm at the threshold per BS 8214.
- Glazing bead damage — replaced with the tested profile if the glazing itself is sound and certified.
Every repair we do is matched to the door's original test evidence, photographed before and after, and signed off under our BM TRADA Q-Mark scheme. The door comes off our report as compliant, with traceability your fire risk assessor can verify.
What Cannot Be Repaired — Replace, Don't Repair
These defects mean the door has lost its certified performance and must be replaced:
- Damaged or compromised door core — the fire-resisting core is not repairable. Any leaf with deep impact damage, water swelling, delamination or burn-through must be replaced.
- Frame warped beyond gap tolerance — if planing won't bring the gap back to 3mm at top and sides, the frame is gone.
- No traceable certification — no plug, no label, no manufacturer's data, no way to prove it was ever fire tested. We cannot certify it as a compliant fire door regardless of condition. Replace with a fully-traceable FD30 or FD60 doorset.
- Modifications outside fire test evidence — adding glazing to a solid-tested door, swapping a single-leaf for a double-leaf, fitting an unrated letterplate, cutting the leaf down. All void the door's certification.
- Wrong fire rating for the location — an FD30 door where Approved Document B and your fire risk assessment require FD60. Replace, don't try to upgrade in place.
- Severe ironmongery overcutting — too many holes, oversized cut-outs, repaired splits in the leaf around lock cases. The leaf's structural integrity is gone.
If your previous contractor "repaired" any of these by sanding, filling, or fitting non-tested components, the door is non-compliant and your audit trail is broken. We see this constantly on remedial surveys.
The Commercial Decision — Repair Cost vs Replacement Cost
Once we've answered the compliance question, the commercial question follows. Roughly:
- A typical fire door repair (seals, closer, hinges, signage) is £60–£180 per door plus materials, completed in a single visit.
- A like-for-like FD30 doorset assembled in-house at our Lincolnshire workshop and fitted starts at around £1,199 supplied and installed for a standard residential opening.
- An FD60 doorset typically runs £900–£1,400 supplied and installed.
That means full replacement is usually 5–10× a repair. But if the repair cost is creeping above £250 per door (multiple components, frame work, glazing) replacement often becomes the better long-term call — you get a new 30-year design life, fresh certification, and one component traceability record per opening rather than a patchwork.
The exception is heritage and bespoke joinery, where replacement may not be like-for-like and a careful repair to original test evidence is the only practical path.
What Stark Does Differently
We don't have a sales target on door sales versus remedials. We genuinely don't care which we quote — we care that the door comes off our scheme as compliant. So on every survey we tell you straight:
- Which doors we can lawfully repair, and what the repair scope is per door.
- Which doors have to be replaced, with the specific test-evidence reason.
- The price for each path and the time on site.
- A single report you can give to your fire risk assessor and (if it ever comes to it) the fire service.
Related reading
- Fire Door Remedial Works — service overview
- 5 Signs Your Fire Door Needs Replacing
- Intumescent Strips & Cold Smoke Seals
- Common Fire Door Defects We Find
Book a Repair-or-Replace Survey
For an honest repair-or-replace survey across Lincolnshire, the East Midlands, South Yorkshire or the West Midlands, call 01522 775570 or email Enquiries@Starkcontracts.co.uk. Most surveys are quoted per door and scheduled within 5–7 working days.