Common Fire Door Failures (and How to Fix Them)

Why Fire Doors Fail

In our experience inspecting fire doors across Lincolnshire and the East Midlands, the same handful of defects come up in almost every building. The good news is that most of them are remediable — and most are caused by one of three things:

  • Wear and tear
  • Poor original installation
  • Day-to-day misuse by occupants

This guide walks through the most common fire door failures we find, why each matters, and how to put it right.

1. Gaps Over 3 mm

The defect: The gap between leaf and frame at the head or sides exceeds the 3 mm tolerance set in BS 8214.

Why it matters: Even a small over-gap allows hot smoke and fire to bypass the intumescent strips before they have time to expand. The door's tested 30- or 60-minute performance is voided.

The fix: Often remediable by adjusting hinges, planing the leaf, or replacing a worn frame. In some cases, full door set replacement is the only certifiable answer.

2. Missing or Damaged Intumescent Strips

The defect: The strips that swell to seal the gap are missing, painted over, cut short, or popped out of the frame groove.

Why it matters: Without continuous intumescent at the head and sides, the door cannot achieve its tested integrity rating. This is the single most common defect we see.

The fix: Strips can be replaced like-for-like to manufacturer specification. If they've been painted, the paint must be carefully removed first — see our painting fire doors guide.

3. Worn or Compressed Smoke Seals

The defect: Brush or fin smoke seals are flattened, split or no longer making contact with the leaf when the door is closed.

Why it matters: Cold smoke kills before fire reaches a door. Compressed seals let it pass freely.

The fix: Replace seals with the same profile and material as the original test evidence. A 5-minute job per door.

4. Self-Closers That Don't Fully Latch

The defect: The door closes to within a few degrees of the keep but doesn't drop into the latch on its own.

Why it matters: A door that doesn't latch is just a door, not a fire door. We see this in 40%+ of doors inspected.

The fix: Adjust the closer's closing speed and latching speed. If the closer is undersized for the door (a size 2 fitted to a heavy fire door, for example), replace with a CE-marked closer of correct power (typically size 3 or 4).

5. Wedges, Hooks and Improvised Hold-Opens

The defect: Fire doors propped open with wedges, hooks, fire extinguishers, chairs or string.

Why it matters: A wedged-open fire door is non-compliant, full stop. It is one of the breaches enforcing officers act on most often. See our hold-open devices regulations.

The fix: Remove wedges. If the door must be open routinely (typically corridors and ward doors), fit an electromagnetic hold-open device linked to the fire alarm.

6. Missing or Painted-Over Certification

The defect: No top-edge plug, no frame label, or labels painted over so they're unreadable.

Why it matters: Without traceable certification, the door cannot be assumed to be fire rated. A painted-over label is treated the same as a missing one.

The fix: If invasive inspection can confirm the door's origin and rating, a re-label or BM TRADA scheme certificate may be issued. If not, the door must be replaced.

7. Damaged Door Leaves

The defect: Splits, deep dents, ironmongery cut-outs that breach the core.

Why it matters: The leaf core is the load-bearing fire element. Damage that breaches the core voids certification.

The fix: Minor cosmetic damage can be filled with manufacturer-approved materials. Damage to the core requires full leaf replacement.

8. Wrong Hinges

The defect: Standard brass or steel hinges fitted in place of CE-marked fire hinges.

Why it matters: Standard hinges fail in a fire and the door drops out of the opening, allowing fire and smoke to pass.

The fix: Replace with at least three CE-marked fire hinges of the correct grade and screw pattern.

9. Wrong or Missing Signage

The defect: "Fire Door — Keep Shut" missing on self-closing doors, or signs on the wrong face.

Why it matters: Signage is part of the assembly's tested specification and a regulatory requirement under BS 5499 / BS EN ISO 7010.

The fix: Trivial — fit the correct sign on the correct face. We do this as part of every remedial visit.

10. Poor Wall Interface (Behind the Architraves)

The defect: The gap between frame and structural opening filled with standard expanding foam, or left open behind the Architraves.

Why it matters: Smoke can bypass the door entirely through the wall cavity.

The fix: Strip the Architraves, fill the gap with mineral wool or fire-rated mastic, refit. This is one of the trickier remedials and almost always needs a competent contractor.

What to Do Next

If your building has any of the above, you have two practical options:

  1. Book a BM TRADA Q-Mark certified inspection to confirm the scope of remedials needed.
  2. Engage a competent remedial contractor who can put the doors right and re-certify them under their scheme.

Get a survey scoped: call Stark Contracts on 01522 775570 or Contact us for a quote and booking.