Fire Door Closers: Overhead vs Concealed — Which Is Right?
Fire Door Closers: Overhead vs Concealed — Which Is Right?
A fire door that doesn't close fully is not a fire door — it's a hole in your compartmentation. That's why every fire door (with rare exceptions) must be fitted with a self-closing device that returns it to the latched position from any opening angle.
But which closer should you choose? Here's how the main options compare.
The Standard: BS EN 1154
All fire door closers must conform to BS EN 1154 and carry CE/UKCA marking. The classification specifies:
- Power size (1–7) — must match door width and weight
- Suitability for fire doors (8th digit must be 1)
- Durability (500,000 cycles minimum)
- Corrosion resistance
For most internal fire doors, power size 3 or 4 is standard. Heavier or wider doors require larger sizes.
Option 1: Overhead Closers
The traditional choice — a visible arm and body fitted to the top of the door or frame.
Pros:
- Powerful and reliable
- Easy to adjust closing speed and latch action
- Cheaper to install and replace
- Visible, so easy to inspect
Cons:
- Aesthetically intrusive — not ideal for hotels or residential corridors
- Can be vandalised in public buildings
- Adjustable arms can be tampered with
Option 2: Concealed Closers (Jamb-Mounted)
Hidden inside the frame and top edge of the door — often called "Perko" or "Perkomatic" style closers.
Pros:
- Almost invisible when door is closed
- Excellent for hotels, residential, and high-end commercial
- Tamper-resistant
Cons:
- Lower power — not suitable for heavy or wide doors
- More expensive to install (frame must be morticed)
- Harder to service and replace
- Not always certified for FD60 use — check before specifying
Option 3: Hold-Open Devices (Magnetic)
Doors held open by magnets that release when the fire alarm sounds. Common on cross-corridor doors and high-traffic routes.
Pros:
- Allows free passage during normal use
- Reduces wear on the closer mechanism
- Excellent for accessibility
Cons:
- Requires connection to fire alarm system
- More expensive (£200+ per door installed)
- Must be tested with the alarm regularly
- The door still needs a certified self-closer behind the magnet
What About Free-Swing Closers?
A specialist option for accessibility — the door swings freely until the alarm activates, then it closes. Often used on dementia care facilities and sheltered accommodation. Requires careful specification and is more expensive than standard closers.
Common Closer Defects in Inspection
From our inspection programme:
- Closer failing to close from any angle — most common defect by far
- Door not latching — usually a power-size issue or worn latch
- Fluid leaks from the closer body
- Hold-open arms illegally installed on closers (defeats the safety function)
- Wedges and door stops — stopping fire doors held open
Specification Help
If you're not sure what to specify, our installation team will recommend the right closer for each door based on weight, width, traffic, and aesthetic requirements — all CE-marked and BS EN 1154 compliant.
Call 01522 775570 or email Enquiries@Starkcontracts.co.uk.